Outsourcing vs. In-House Bookkeeping: Pros and Cons 

Remote bookkeeping teams can greatly benefit business owners as they provide access to skilled professionals who focus on improving business operations and increasing profits. This method can also lead to significant cost savings compared to having an in-house department.

The main reasons for outsourcing include cost savings, emphasis on core business operations, and addressing capacity challenges. Like any good decision, it begins with evaluating the pros and cons to determine whether outsourced bookkeeping services fit your company. 

Outsourcing vs. In-House Bookkeeping

Source: Andrey_Popov/Shutterstock.com

Outsourcing Bookkeeping 

Remote bookkeeping services allow you to entrust your company’s fiscal responsibilities to external professionals. These services generally cover various tasks such as recording transactions, managing payroll, preparing statements, and handling tax filings.

These platforms offer live bookkeepers who provide tailored services to meet your business objectives. This approach comes with pros and cons, which include:

Pro #1: Cost Savings

You save on salaries, benefits, and training costs by eliminating the need for an on-site team. This model allows you to pay only for the features you use, making it a cost-effective option, especially for small to medium-sized firms.

Pro #2: Access to Expertise

Third-party services provide access to accounting professionals with years of specialized experience. These trained professionals often have certifications in the latest software and may hold CPA qualifications, meaning you benefit from their education and skill set without hiring a new team member.

Pro #3: Frees Up Time and Resources 

Delegating cash flow management tasks allocates more time and resources to core activities, such as acquiring new customers or creating new products. This lets you grow and develop the business rather than spend hours on fiscal tasks.

Pro #4: Scalability

If you use scalable solutions from outside your company, you can easily adjust them to fit your growing needs. As your company expands, you can modify the support you get from the service provider and access more features without hiring more staff. This way, you can save on costs and still get the support you need.

Con #1: Reduced Control

Handing over financial tasks to an outside party can lead to less immediate control and a risk of losing touch with the company’s internal processes and culture. However, remote bookkeepers can help you minimize this potential downside of contracted accounting. These professionals get to know you and your company and provide solutions tailored to your firm’s needs and culture.

In-House Bookkeeping

Source: Ground Picture/Shutterstock.com

Con #2: Security Concerns

Giving sensitive economic data to an external firm might raise concerns about data security and mishandling confidential details. However, most providers have strong security protocols, such as end-to-end encryption and multi-factor authentication. These measures only allow those with proper approval to access your company’s data, giving you peace of mind.

Con #3: Communication Challenges

If you’re worried about using remote record-keeping because of communication issues, like being unable to access your data or receive customer service help, you’ll be happy to know that virtual technologies have advanced. You can now use video chat to contact your remote bookkeeper to ask for one-on-one support, share documents, or get answers to any questions.

Also Read: Paycor Login: Streamline Your Payroll and HR Management

In-House Bookkeeping 

Managing the books internally typically requires recruiting and training staff to undertake different responsibilities, including recording transactions, managing payroll, creating revenue statements, and maintaining tax compliance.

Having your own team offers more direct supervision, closer involvement with your organization’s daily operations, and immediate on-site support. However, this method typically incurs higher long-term costs and may necessitate comprehensive staff training.

When contemplating an on-site team, it’s important to weigh these pros and cons: 

Pro #1: Greater Control

An internal team gives you greater control over financial operations, enabling tight oversight and management to align with company policies and goals. However, this also places the responsibility of fulfilling all reporting and tax obligations on you and your team.

Pro #2: Immediate Access

An internal team provides direct access to cash flow records and fiscal administration personnel. This arrangement allows you to receive immediate budget updates, quickly resolve inquiries, and have face-to-face interactions, which helps you manage your budget more efficiently.

Pro #3: Enhanced Security

With the right resources, in-house business bookkeeping can provide maximal security for sensitive financial information. Keeping records stored on-premises offers complete control over data access and encryption. However, this requires implementing your own security protocols and could mean hiring an external IT team, depending on your needs and capabilities. 

Con #1: Higher Costs

Maintaining a company-based team can be expensive. The average payroll specialist salary ranges from $34,000 to $61,000 annually, and this doesn’t cover extra expenses such as benefits, training, and office space. For smaller companies or startups, this can represent a considerable investment.

Con #2: Limited Expertise

An internal team might not have the varied expertise that contracted bookkeepers provide. They may not always be current with the newest accounting software or tax regulations, potentially resulting in inefficiencies or mistakes in managing finances. This drawback can pose difficulties for firms with complex reporting requirements or limited experience with tax and reporting compliance.

Con #3: Potential for Distraction

Having an in-house bookkeeping team may cause them to handle other operational tasks. Financial management personnel tend to get involved in daily operational issues, which may affect their concentration on financial duties. This challenge is especially true for companies with limited resources and staff, which may result in cash flow challenges and reconciliation problems that can negatively affect the company’s financial health.

Con #4: Staffing Challenges

Hiring, training, and keeping skilled staff can be costly and time-intensive. Locating individuals with the required expertise and experience presents a challenge, and employee turnover can disrupt consistent record-keeping and continuity.

Also Read: Maximizing Efficiency with SAP GRC Audit Management

Factors to Consider When Choosing a Solution for Your Business

Choosing the right bookkeeping option for your business depends on several important factors. Carefully assess the following to make sure your choice matches your organization’s current requirements and long-term objectives:

Company Size

When deciding on a record-keeping method, consider the size of your operations. For smaller companies with limited employees, opting for an outsourced solution can save time and avoid the complexities of mastering intricate accounting systems.


Think about your budget when determining the right approach. If your firm aims to minimize costs, an external accountant could be the way to go, offering various pricing options to match your budget. 

Complexity of Bookkeeping Needs

When it comes to your finances, it’s important to assess the complexity of your activities. If you need help with bookkeeping tasks, consider outsourcing to experts with the proper knowledge and experience. They can be beneficial when dealing with situations like multi-state tax nexus or international taxes that can be challenging to handle in-house.

Timely Data Access 

Outsourcing can be a good option when you need quick access to your transactional data and inquiries. It offers the responsiveness you need for quick decision-making. These services use innovative software that provides real-time reporting capabilities, giving you direct access to your financial information.

Future Growth Plans

When planning for the future, consider how your economic needs might evolve. If your venture is set to grow or diversify, outsourced bookkeepers can provide scalable solutions that adapt to changing demands. 

In-House Bookkeeping

Source: Prostock-studio/Shutterstock.com

Also Read: Tallyman Axis: The Future of Data Management

Make the Most Cost-Effective Choice for Your Business

Balancing the potential benefits and drawbacks is essential when choosing between outsourced and in-house financial management. Consider how each option fits your budget, the level of control you want, security needs, and access to financial expertise. 

Matching these with your organization’s specific requirements and growth ambitions will help you determine the best approach for your company’s development.

Leave a Reply